The great minds in Bush's Homeland Security department came up with a doozie this year: let's move the facility where we study the most infectious and dangerous disease among livestock from the isolated island it's now on (accessible only by ferry or helicopter) and put it where there are lots of livestock operations. Brilliant!
Seriously, the Bush administration proposed this, despite the fact that the existing lab has experienced accidents where the virus was released.
A 1978 release of the virus into cattle holding pens on Plum Island, N.Y., triggered new safety procedures. While that incident was previously known, the Homeland Security Department told a House committee there were other accidents inside the government's laboratory.
The accidents are significant because the administration is likely to move foot-and-mouth research from the remote island to one of five sites on the U.S. mainland near livestock herds. This has raised concerns about the risks of a catastrophic outbreak of the disease, which does not sicken humans but can devastate the livestock industry.
Among the big brains at work here is Kansas Sen. Pat Roberts, who's all for the move because Kansas is one of the locations under consideration. This despite the fact that in a 2002 exercise, he played the President.
A simulated outbreak of the disease in 2002 — part of an earlier U.S. government exercise called "Crimson Sky" — ended with fictional riots in the streets after the simulation's National Guardsmen were ordered to kill tens of millions of farm animals, so many that troops ran out of bullets. In the exercise, the government said it would have been forced to dig a ditch in Kansas 25 miles long to bury carcasses. In the simulation, protests broke out in some cities amid food shortages.
The hoof and mouth disease can spread like wildfire, carried in the air, in the feed, on feeding utensils, vehicles, clothing, or holding facilities contaminated with the virus. And it can spread between species to any cloven-hooved animal, including wildlife. That means deer and elk could be exposed and carry the virus over a huge range.
Luckily, a couple of Demcoratic congressmen--neither of them Joe Lieberman, whose job it would be as chair of the Senate Homeland Security Committee--have stepped in, and conducted an investigation
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Bush administration has no evidence to support its contention that it would be safe to move research on highly infectious foot-and-mouth disease to the U.S. mainland near livestock, congressional investigators said Thursday.
Two Democratic committee leaders said it would be foolish and dangerous for the administration to move ahead with those plans, given the risk of an animal epidemic if the virus escapes.... Rep. John Dingell, chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, said plans by the Department of Homeland Security were not only "baffling, but dangerous."
"It will be farmers and ranchers who bear the risk" of the world's most infectious animal-only disease, Dingell said. Rep. Bart Stupak, chairman of the panel's investigative subcommittee, said the move "would be a foolish tempting of fate." Both are Michigan Democrats.
But Rep. Charles "Chip" Pickering Jr., R-Miss., pointed out that a strong bipartisan majority supports a provision in a major farm bill that would allow the move to the mainland. Pickering said a new laboratory would be safe on the mainland including in his state — where Flora, Miss. is one of five finalists for the mainland site.
The one certainty in the debate that has divided the commercial livestock industry: making the wrong choice could bring on an economic catastrophe.
Which is, of course, why the research facility has been isolated on Plum Island for the past half-century. Here's just one more example demonstrating how much the Bush administration and the Republicans in Congress really do care about national security. While the disease wouldn't infect humans, the economic devastation an outbreak could incur would qualify it as a potential terrorist threat. There have already been accidents in the research facility, as there always are when humans are involved. What prevented catastrophe in those six accidents was the fact that the outbreaks were confined to the island.
The take-away lesson from this story: Democrats should cede no ground to the Republicans on "national security" this election year.